粉丝1.1万获赞87.1万

男人必看的四部纪录片,我想搞钱,你有没有办法提高我的认知?记得保存,搞钱先搞脑,认知上到有钱那是迟早的事。按我说的顺序,看完这四部纪录片,你的财富至少翻十倍!一、绿色星球, 以植物的视角深入体验生存挑战。二、解码比尔盖茨的视角里,这个世界居然是这样的。三、心智斗争,一部认知之阿列的纪录片。四、自我认知,带你真正深入了解认识自己。

男人必看的四部纪录片,我想搞钱,你有没有办法提高我的认知?记得保存,搞钱先搞脑,认知上到有钱那是迟早的事。按我说的顺序,看完这四部纪录片,你的财富至少翻十倍! 一、绿色星球,以植物的视角深入体验生存挑战。二、解码比尔盖茨的视角里,这个世界居然是这样的。三、心智斗争,一部认知炸裂的纪录片。四、自我认知,带你真正深入了解认识吧自己。

肚里没墨、脑子没货,竟狂刷着三十六部纪录片提升财商看这六个,提高心力看这六个,提升情商表达看这六个,强化思维逻辑。看这六个,提升历史文化看这六个,享受人间美食看这六个!


男人必看的四部纪录片,我想搞钱,你有没有办法提高我的认知?记得保存,搞钱先搞脑,认知上到有钱那是迟早的事。按我说的顺序,看完这四部纪录片,你的财富至少翻十倍! 一、绿色星球,以植物的视角深入体验生存挑战。二、解码比尔盖茨的视角里,这个世界居然是这样的。三、形制斗争,一部认知炸裂的纪录片。四、自我认知,带你真正深入了解认识自己。

but the area of our lives in which these systematic mistakes have the most explosive impact is in the world of money the moment money enters the picture the rules change many of us think that we're at our most rational when it comes to decisions about money we like to think we know how to spot a bargain to strike a good deal sell our house at the right time invest wisely thinking about money the right way is one of the most challenging things for human nature but if we're not as rational as we like to think and there is a hidden force at work shaping our decisions are we deluding ourselves money brings with it in mode of thinking it's changed the way we react to the world when it comes to money cognitive biases play havoc with our best intentions there are many mistakes that people make when it comes to money karnaments insight into our mistakes with money were to revolutionize our understanding of economics it's all about a crucial difference in how we feel when we win or lose and our readiness to take a risk willingness to take a gamble is very different depending on whether we're faced with a loss or a game excuse me guys you spare two minutes to help us with a little experiment we have to try and win as much money as you can okay, okay okay! in my hands here i have twenty pounds here are two scenarios and i'm gonna give you ten in the first case you are given ten pounds that's now yours put it in your pocket take it away spend it on a drink on the south bank later okay, okay then you have to make a choice about how much more you could gain you can either take a safe option in which case i'll give you an additional five or you can take a risk and take a risk i'm going to flip this coin, but it comes up heads you in ten, but if it comes up tails you're not going to win anymore would you choose the safe option and get an extra five pounds or take a risk and maybe win an extra ten or nothing which is it gonna be i'd go safe safe five yeah take five you take five yeah man sure there we go most people presented with this choice go for the certainty of the extra fiver thank you very much all right told you it was easy in a winning frame of mind people are naturally rather cautious that's yours too oh that was it that was it really yes yeah but what about losing are we similarly cautious when faced with a potential loss hey my hands i've got twenty pounds i'm gonna give that to you that's no yours you can put it in your handbag this time you're given twenty pounds and again you must make a choice would you choose to accept a safe loss of five pounds or would you take a risk if you take a risk i'm gonna flip this coin if it comes up heads you don't lose anything but if it comes up tails then you lose ten pounds in fact it's exactly the same outcome in both cases you face a choice between ending up with a certain fifteen pounds or tossing a coin to get either ten or twenty i will risk these in town on this okay but the crucial surprise here is that when the choices framed in terms of a loss people take a risk take a risk take a risk okay, i'll risk it you'll risk it okay our slow system too could probably work out that the outcome is the same in both cases and that's heads you win, but it's too limited and too lazy that's the easiest twenty phones you'll ever make instead fast system one makes a rough guess based on change and that's all there is to it thank you very much wherever you want and system one doesn't like losing if you were to lose ten pounds in the street today, and then fine ten pounds tomorrow you would be financially unchanged, but actually we respond to changes so the pain of the loss of ten pounds looms much larger it feels more painful in fact probably have to find twenty pounds to offset the pain that you feel by losing ten at the heart of this is a bias called loss of version which affects many of our financial decisions people think in terms of games and losses it's tale and in there thinking typically losses loom larger than games we even have an idea by how much and by roughly a factor of two or a little more than two that is loss of ocean and it certainly was the most important thing that emotional work it's a vital insight into human behavior so important it led to a nobel prize and the founding of an entire new branch of economics when we think we're winning, we don't take risks but when we're faced with a loss frankly, we're a bit reckless。

cycologists alive today his insides come largely from puzzles take for instance the curious puzzle of new york cap drivers and their highly illogical working habits business varies according to the weather on rainy days, everyone wants a cab but on sunny days like today fairs are hard to find logically they should spend a lot of time driving on rainy days because it's very easy to find passengers on rainy days and if they are going to take leisure it should be on sunny days but it turns out this is not what many of them do many do the opposite working long hours on slow sunny days and knocking off early when it's rainy and busy instead of thinking logically the cabbies are driven by an urge to earn a set amount of cash each day come rain or shine once they hit the target they go home they view being below the target as a loss and being above the target as a gain and they care more about preventing the loss than about achieving the gain so when they reach their goal on a rainy day they stop which really doesn't make sense if they were trying to maximize their income they would take their easier on sunny days and they would drive all day on rainy days it was this kind of glitch in thinking that carnamon realized could reveal something profound about the inner workings of the mind he began to devise a series of puzzles and questions which have become classic psychological tests posing problems where you can recognize in yourself that your intuition is going the wrong way the type of puzzle where the answer that intuitively springs to mind and that seems obvious is in fact wrong here is one that i think works on just about everybody i want you to imagine a guy called steve you tell people that steve you know is a make and tidy soul with a passion for detail and very little interesting people he's got a good eye for detail and then you tell people he was drawn at random from a senses of the american population with the probability that he is a farmer or a librarian so do you think it's more likely that steve's gonna end up working as a librarian or a farmer what's he more likely to be maybe a librarian librarian probably a librarian a librarian immediately you know a thought pops to mind that it's a librarian because he resemble the prototype of library probably a librarian in fact that's probably the wrong answer because at least in the united states there are twenty times as many male formers as male librarians librarian librarian that probably more meek and tidy souls you know who are farmers and meek and tidy souls who are librarians? so we had examples like that like many of them what makes them interesting is that they're not random errors their biases so the difference that in a bias and a random era is that a bias is predictable it's a pattern of human error that affects every single one of us on their own they may seem small oh that seems to be the right drawer but by rummaging around in our everyday mistakes that's very odd carnament started a revolution in our understanding of human thinking a revolution so profound and far reaching that he was awarded and nobel prized so if you want to see the metal that's what it looks like that's it。

professor chris shebree is about to start a fight all right so what i want you guys to do is stay in this area over here the two big guys grab you and sort of like start pretending to punch you make some sound effects it's part of an experiment that shows a pretty shocking mistake that any one of us could make a mistake where you don't notice what's happening right in front of your eyes as well as a fight the experiment also involves a chase it was inspired by an incident in boston in nineteen ninety five when a young police officer kenny conley was in hot pursuit of a murder suspect turned out that this police officer while he was chasing the suspect had run right past some other police officers who were beating up another suspect which of course police officers are not supposed to do under any circumstances when the police tried to investigate this case of police brutality he said i didn't see anything going on there all i saw was the suspect i was chasing and nobody could believe this and he was prosecuted for perjury an obstruction of justice everyone was convinced that conley was lying he wondered if our ability to pay attention is so limited that any one of us could run past a vicious fight without even noticing and it's something he's putting to the test and when you see someone jogging across the foot bridge then you should get started jackie you can go in the experiment the subjects are asked to focus carefully on a cognitive task they must count the number of times the runner taps her head with each hand would they like the boston police officer be so blinded by their limited attention that they would completely fail to notice the fight about forty five seconds or a minute into the run there was the fight and they could actually see the fight from a ways away and it was about twenty feet away from them when they got closest to them the fight is right in their field of view and at least partially visible from as far back as the foot bridge it seems incredible that anyone would fail to notice something so apparently obvious they completed the three minute course and then we said did you notice anything unusual what was it it was a fight sometimes they would have noticed the fight and they would say yeah i saw some guys fighting but a large percentage of people said we didn't see anything unusual at all and when we asked them specifically about whether they saw anybody fighting they still said no in fact nearly fifty percent of people in the experiment completely failed to notice the fight did you see anything unusual during the run no okay did you see some people fighting no we did it at nighttime and we did it in the daylight even when we did it in daylight many people ran right past the fight and didn't notice it at all did you see anything unusual during the run no not really okay did you see some people fighting and now you really didn't see anyone fighting now does it surprise you to you could have missed that they were about twenty feet off the path oh yeah you ran right past them completely missed that then okay maybe what happened to conley was when you're really paying attention to one thing and focusing a lot of mental energy on it you can miss things that other people are gonna think are completely obvious and in fact that's what the jurors said after conley's trial, they said we couldn't believe that he could miss something like that it didn't make any sense he had to have been lying it's an unsettling phenomenon called inattentional blindness that can affect us all some people have said things like this shatters my faith and my own mind or now i don't know what to believe or i'm gonna be confused from now on, but i'm not sure that that feeling really stays with them very long they are gonna go out from the experiment, you know walk to the next place they're going or something like that and they're going to have just as much inattentional blindness when they're walking down the street that afternoon as they did before this experiment reveals a powerful quandary about our minds we glide through the world blissfully unaware of most of what we do, and how little we really know our minds for all its brilliance the part of our mind we call ourselves is extremely limited so how do we manage to navigate our way through the complexity of daily life。

脑子里没货,请疯狂去刷这四十八部宝藏纪录片!提升财商看这六个,提升表达看这六个!心理疗愈看这六个,提升思维看这六个,美食文化看这六个!提升文化底蕴看这六个!历史传记看这六个,国际视野看这六个!

what happens? if you're an expert trained in making decisions that are a matter of life and death are you still destined to make these systematic mistakes on the outskirts of washington? d c horizon has been granted access to spy on the spooks welcome to analytic exercise number four former intelligence analyst donald cretz is running an ultra realistic spy game this exercise will take place in the fictitious city of vastopolis taking part are a mixture of trained intelligence analysts and some novices due to an emerging threat a terrorism task force has been stood up i will be the terrorism task force lead and i have recruited all of you to be our terrorism analysts the challenge facing the analysts is to thwart a terrorist threat against a us city the threat at this point has not been determined it's up to you to figure out the type of terrorism and who's responsible for planning it the analysts face a number of tasks they must first investigate any groups who may pose a threat your task is to write a report the subject in this case is the network of dread the mayor has asked for this fifteen minutes from now just like in the real world the analysts have access to a huge amount of data streaming in from government, agencies, social media, mobile phones and emergency services。 the network of dread turns out to be a well known international terror group they have the track record the capability and the personnel to carry out an attack the scenario that's emerging is a bio terror event meaning it's a biological terrorism attack that's going to take place against the city if there is an emerging threat, they are the likely candidate need to move on to the next task it's now nine april this is another request for information this time on something or someone called the masters of chaos the masters of chaos are a group of cyber hackers a local bunch of misfits with no history of violence and while the analysts continue to sift through the incoming data behind the scenes cretz is watching their every move in this room we're able to monitor what the analysts are doing throughout the entire exercise? we have set up a knowledge base into which we have been inserting data throughout the course of the day some of them are related to our terrorist threat many of them are not amidst the wealth of data on the known terror group, there's also evidence coming in of a theft at a university biology lab and someone has hacked into the computers of a local freight firm the stakes are incredibly high mistakes can often be life and death we roll ahead now the date is twenty one may if the analysts are able to think rationally they should be able to solve the puzzle, but the danger is they will fall into the trap set by credits and only pay attention to the established terror group the network of dread their judgment may be clouded by a bias called confirmation bias confirmation bias is the most prevalent bias of all and that's where we tend to search for information that supports what we already believe confirmation bias can easily lead people to ignore the evidence in front of their eyes and cretz is able to monitor if the bias kicks in we still see that they're searching for network of dread that's an indication that we may have a confirmation bias operating the network of dread are the big guys they've done it before so you would expect they'd do it again and i think we're starting to see some biases here analysts desperately want to get to the correct answer, but they're affected by the same biases as the rest of us so far most of our analysts seem to believe that the network of dread is responsible for planning this attack and that is completely wrong how are we doing it's time for the analysts to put themselves on the line and decide who the terrorists are and what they're planning? so what do you think it was a bio terrorist good attack i had a different theory all right, so wish we should be because i may be missing something here too they know that the network of dread is a terrorist group, they know that the masters of chaos is a cyber hacking group either to the meat factory we're in the water supply the question is did any of the analysts manage to dig out the relevant clues and find the true threat in this case, the actual threat is due to a cyber group the masters of chaos who becomes increasingly radicalized throughout the scenario and decides to take out their anger on society essentially who convinced them to switch from cyber crime to bioterrorism or did they succumb to confirmation by us and simply pin the blame on the usual suspects will they make that connection will they process that evidence and assess it accordingly or will their confirmation bias drive them to believe that it's a more traditional type of terrorist group i believe that the masters of chaos have actually the ones behind it it's either a threat or not a threat but the network is red and time's up please go ahead and save those reports at the end of the exercise cretz reveals the true identity of the terrorists we have a priority message from city hall the terrorist attack was thwarted the planned bioterrorist attack by the masters of chaos against vestopolis was thwarted the mary expresses his thanks for a job well done show a hands who got it yeah out of twelve subjects eleven of them got the wrong answer the only person to spot the true threat was in fact a novice all the trained experts fell prey to confirmation bias, it is not typically the case that simply being trained as an analyst gives you the tools you need to overcome cognitive bias you can learn techniques for memory improvement you can learn techniques for better focus, but techniques to eliminate cognitive bias just simply don't work and for intelligence analysts in the real world the implications of making mistakes from these biases are drastic government reports and studies over the past decade or so have sighted experts as believing that cognitive bias may have played a role in a number of very significant intelligence failures and yet it remains an understudy problem。

since carnament first began investigating the glitches in our thinking more than a hundred and fifty cognitive biases have been identified we are riddled with these systematic mistakes and they affect every aspect of our daily lives, the compete has a very big list of bio season we are finding new ones all the time one of the biases that i think is the most important is what's called the present bias focus? it's the fact that we focus on now and don't think very much about the future and that's the bias that causes things like overeating and smoking and texting and driving and having unprotected sex。 another one is called the halo effect and this is the idea that if you like somebody or an organization you're biased to think that all of its aspects are good not everything is good about it if you dislike it everything is about people, really are quite uncomfortable you know by the idea that hitler love love children he did now that doesn't make him a good person but but we feel uncomfortable to see an attractive trait in a person that we consider you know the epitome evil we're prone to think that what we like is all good and what we dislike is all bad that's a bias another particular favorite of mine is the bias to get attached to things that we ourselves have created we call it the akia effect well, you've got loss of version risk aversion present bias spotlight effect and the spotlight effect is the idea that we think that other people people pay lots of attention to us when in fact, they don't confirmation bias over confidence is a big one, but what's clear is that there's lots of them, there's lots of ways for us to get things wrong you know there's one way to do things right and many ways to do things wrong and we're capable of many of them these biases explain so many things that we get wrong our impulsive spending trusting the wrong people not seeing the other person's point of view succumbing to temptation we are so riddled with these biases it's hard to believe we ever make a rational decision, but it's not just our everyday decisions that are affected。

every day each one of us makes somewhere between two and ten thousand decisions when you think about our daily lives, it's really a long long sequence of decisions we make decisions probably at the frequency that is close to the frequency we breathe every minute every second you're deciding where to move your legs and where to move your eyes and where to move your limbs and when you're eating a meal or you're making all kinds of decisions and yet the vast majority of these decisions we make without even realizing it was danny conaman's insight that we have two systems in the mind for making decisions two ways of thinking fast and slow you know our mind is really two ways of operating and one is sort of fast thinking an automatic effortless mode and that's the one we're in most of the time this fast automatic mode of thinking he called system one it's powerful, effortless and responsible for most of what we do and system one is you know that's what happens most of the time, you're there the world around you provides all kinds of stimuli and you respond to them everything that you see and that you understand you know this is a tree that's a helicopter back there that's a statue of liberty all of this visual perception all of this come through system one the other mode is slow deliberate, logical and rational this is system two and it's the bet you think of as you the voice in your head the simplest example of the two systems is really two plus two is on one side and seventeen time twenty four is on the other what is two plus two four four four fast system one is always in gear producing instant answers is automatic you do not intend for it to happen it just happens to you it's almost like a reflex and what's that twenty two times seventeen that's a good one but when we have to pay attention to a tricky problem we engage slow but logical system too if you can do that in your head, you'll have to follow some rules and to do it sequentially and that is not a dramatic at all that involves work it involves effort it involves concentration twenty two times seventeen there will be physiological symptoms your heart rate will accelerate your pupils will dilate so many changes will occur while you are performing this computation for three seventy four okay and can i get you to just walk with me for a second who's the current system too may be clever but it's also slow limited and lazy i live in berkeley during summers and i walk a lot and when i walk very fast, i cannot think can i get you to count backwards from one hundred by seven sure one hundred ninety three eighty it's hard when you're walking, it takes up interestingly enough the same kind of executive function as thinking forty four four if you are expected to do something that demands a lot of effort, you will stop even walking eighty six fifty one six everything that you're aware of in your own mind is part of this slow deliberative system too as far as you are concerned it is the star of the show actually, i describe system too as another star i describe it as as a minor character who thinks he is the star because in fact most of it goes on in our mind is automatic and you know it's in the domain that they call system one system one is an old if old bit of a brain and it's remarkable, we couldn't survive without it because system two would explode if mr spock had to make every decision for us, it would be very slow and effortful and our heads would explode and this fast hidden domain is responsible for far more than you would possibly believe having an opinion you have an opinion immediately whether you like it or not whether you like something or not whether you for something or not liking someone and not liking them that quite often is something you have no control over later when you're asked for reasons, you will invent reasons and a lot of what system two does is it provides reason it provides rationalizations which are not necessarily the true reasons for our beliefs in our emotions and our intentions and what we do you have two systems of thinking that steer you through life? fast intuitive system one that is incredible, incredibly powerful and does most of the driving and slow logical system too that is clever but a little lazy trouble is there's a bit of a battle between them as to which one is driving your decisions that happens as i ask you a question and if the question is difficult, but there is a related question that is a lot that is somewhat simpler you're just going to answer the other question and and not even notice so the system does all kinds of shortcuts to feed us the information in the fast way, we can make actions and the system is accepting some mistakes we make decisions using fast system one when we really should be using slow system two, and this is why we make the mistakes we do systematic mistakes known as cognitive biases。

but loss of version doesn't just affect people making casual five pound beds it can affect anyone at any time including those who work in the complex system of high finance in which trillions of dollars are traded in our current complex environments we now have the means as well as the motive to make very serious mistakes the bedrock of economics is that people think rationally they calculate risks rewards and decide accordingly, but we're not always rational we rarely behave like mr spock for most of our decisions we use fast intuitive but occasionally unreliable system one and in a global financial market that can lead to very serious problems i think what the financial crisis did was it simply said you know what people are a lot more vulnerable to psychological pitfalls then we really understood before basically human psychology is just too flawed to expect that we could avert a crisis understanding these pitfalls has led to a new branch of economics behavioral economics thanks to psychologists like her chefren it's beginning to establish a tow hold in wall street, it takes account of the way we actually make decisions rather than how we say we do financial crisis i think was as larger problem as it was because certain psychological traits like optimism over confidence and confirmation bias played a very large role among a part of the economy where serious the stakes could be made and work but for as long as our financial system assumes we are rational our economy will remain vulnerable i'm quite certain if they regulators listen to behavior economists early on we would have designed a very different financial system and we wouldn't have had the incredible increase in housing market, and we wouldn't have this financial catastrophe and so when carnament collected his nobel prize it wasn't for psychology it was for economics。

the big question is what can we do about these systematic mistakes can we hope to find a way round our fast thinking biases and make better decisions to answer this we need to know the evolutionary origins of our mistakes just of the coast of queto rico is probably the best place in the world to find out it's an island devoted to monkey research see the guys hanging out on the clip up there lori santos is here to find out if monkeys make the same mistakes in their decisions that we do working to us comparing humans and other points trying to ask what's special about them really what we want to understand is what's the evolutionary origin of some of our dumber strategies some of us possible we get things wrong if we get understand where those cave drugs that's what we get santos can show us that monkeys have the same cognitive biases of those would suggest they evolve the long time ago and the mental strategy that old would be almost impossible to change we started this work around the time of the financial collapse, so when we were thinking about what dumb strategies could look at monkeys it was pretty obviously the human economic strategies with revenues might be the first thing to look at and one of the particular things we need to want to look at whether or not it's not possible but monkeys are as smart as they are yet to stop using monkeys and so that was kind of where we started instead while huggling and question for this one music financial mistakes and so we decided to do it by introducing very much use of your own new currency and just let them buy their food so i'll show you some of this stuff we think up to you with the monkeys back in her lab of yale, she introduced a troop of monkeys to their own market giving them brown shiny toke for exchange for food of your colleagues which come in and over token you can see she just gets you grabbed it right there one of the first things we wondered was just convene some sense learned that a different store sells different food at different prices so what we did was we presented the monkeys with situations where they met traders who sold different goods at different rates so what you'll see in this clip is the monkeys meeting a new trader she's actually selling grapes for three grapes per one token and what we found is that in this case the monkeys are pretty rational so when they get a choice of a guy who sells three goods for one token they actually shop more at that guy having taught the monkeys the value of money the next next step was to see if monkeys like humans suffer from that most crucial bias loss of version and so what we did was we introduce the monkeys to traders who either gave out losses or gains relative to what they showed so i could make the monkey think he's getting a bonus simply by having him trade with a trader who's starting with a single grape but then when the monkey pays this trader she actually gives him an extra, so she gives him a bonus at the end the monkey gets too, but he thinks he got that second one as a bonus we can then compare what the monkeys do with that guy versus a guy who gives the monkey losses this is a guy who shows up who pretends he's going to sell three grapes but then when the monkey actually pays this trader he'll take one of the grapes away and give the monkeys only two the big question then is how the monk is react when faced with a choice between a loss and again so she'll come in she's met these two guys before you can see she goes with the bonus option even waits patiently for her additional piece to be added here and then takes the bonus avoiding the person who gives her losses so monkeys hate losing just as much as people and crucially santos found that monkeys as well are more likely to take risks when faced with a loss this suggests to us that the monkeys seem to frame their decisions in exactly the same way we do they're not thinking just about the absolute they're thinking relative to what they expect and when they're getting less than they expect when they're getting losses they too become more risk seeking the fact that we share this bias with these monkeys suggests it's an ancient strategy etched into our dna more than thirty five million years ago and what we learned from the monkeys is that if this bias is really that old, if we really have had this strategy for the last thirty five million years simply deciding to overcome it is just not gonna work we need better ways to make ourselves avoid some of these pitfalls mistakes it seems is just part of what it is to be human we are stuck with our intuitive in a stranger the challenge this poses is profound if it's human nature to make these predictable mistakes and we can't change that what then can we do we need to accept ourselves as we are the cool thing about being a human versus a monkey is that we have a deliberative self that can reflect on our biases system two in us has for the first time realized there's a system one and with that realization we can shape the way, we set up policies, we can shape the way, we set up situations to allow ourselves to make better decisions this is the first time in evolution this is how if we want to avoid mistakes, we have to reshape the environment we've built around us rather than hope to change ourselves we've achieved a lot despite all of these biases if we are aware of them, we can probably do things like design our institutions and our regulations and our own personal environments and working lives to minimize the effect of those biases and help us think about how to overcome them we are limited, we're not perfect we're irrational in all kinds of ways, but we can build the world that is compatible with this and get us to make better decisions rather than worth decisions that's my home and by accepting our inner stranger we may come to a better understanding of our own minds i think it is important in general to be aware of where beliefs come from and if we think that we have reasons for what we believe that is often a mistake that our beliefs and our wishes and our hopes are not always anchored in reasons they're anchored in something else that comes from within and is different。

一个用五千美元滚成一千五百万的男人告诉你,亏钱的人,其实是他自己想亏。你听完热血沸腾,觉得终于有人说了真话。但你有没有想过,说这句话的人,恰好是那个赢了的人?今天你会拿到一把工具, 不是如何像赛克塔一样交易,而是如何识别一条交易信条到底是普世真理,还是某个幸存者的运气,被包装成了智慧?而且我会一路挖到连我自己这把刀都砍到自己手上的地方。 先说清楚,如果你正拿着不能亏的钱,指望三个月靠交易翻身,现在就关掉。这期内容会让你更焦虑,而不是更赚钱。先离开牌桌,稳住现金流, 这不是客气,是适用边界。艾迪赛科塔,一九四六年生, m i t, 电器工程出身。一九七零年代初,个人电脑还没影子。他用打孔卡片和大型机写出了最早的一批可回测、可自动发信号的商用交易系统。 杰克施瓦格把他写进金融怪节,一战封神。流传最广的数字是一个客户约五千美元的账户,十几年滚到一千五百万美元。以上。 口径各版本略有出入,但量计如此。他最出名的一句话是被问好交易的要素时的回答。他说,第一,砍掉亏损,第二,砍掉亏损,第三,砍掉亏损。 大多数人的第一反应是,哦,止损吗?纪律吗?懂了,然后划过去。但你有没有想过一个问题,一个逻辑精密到能写交易系统的工程师,为什么用重复三遍这种近乎宗教口号的方式说话? 因为他重复三遍,不是因为规则复杂,是因为他简单到你一定会违反他对抗的不是你的无知,是你的天性。 这就把我们逼下一层。你为什么砍不掉亏损?做个身体实验,你的福亏从百分之二扩大到百分之八。此刻你身体在发生什么?手心出汗,胃部收紧,一种再等等,他会回来的黏糯感。 这不是意志薄弱,是几万年前的祖先留给你的。想象一下,草原上你的祖先面对损失被抢走的肉受的伤,本能反应是不惜代价挽回,绝不认亏。因为在没有第二次机会的环境里,认亏往往等于死。 损失厌恶在草原上是保命的免疫系统,但市场是逆草原环境,在这里认亏离场才保命,死扛才致命。你的祖先本能被完美错配了。 赛科塔的天才在于他没试图战胜本能,因为工程师知道意志力会耗尽。他把纪律从意志外包给了系统,系统在你出汗之前就发出平舱信号,你只需要执行。这是系统交易的地基级机制,他不预测市场, 他在你和你自己的基因之间差一道防火墙。那砍掉亏损到底在防御什么?他不保证赚钱,只会砍损的人可能被小止损磨死。 他防御的是唯一一种不可逆的死法,爆仓归零,趋势跟踪的收益结构是小亏很多次,大赚极少次。只要你在牌桌上,那几次,大趋势就会来。 砍损的真正功能是让你活到大趋势那天。他像免疫系统,免疫系统的工作不是让你更强壮,是阻止你死于一次致命感染。这也是他那句木志明的意思,有老交易员,但很少有又老又猛的交易员。 大多数人以为系统交易是为了更准的预测未来,但实际上它压根不预测。它只是一套把你自己关起来,防止你自杀的装置。记住这个感觉,同一套本能,草原上救你命,市场里要你命。故事到这里听起来,完美 工程师用系统战胜了人性,但你怎么解释他人生后半场几乎离开了交易部落,专门做交易员的情绪与心理治疗,这是最深的张力所在。 系统能外包纪律,但系统运行的前提是你情绪上愿意服从它,而这个外包不掉。 当系统连续十次亏损,账户回撤百分之三十,你会开始优化它,跳过信号,亲手拆掉自己造的防火墙。塞克塔比谁都更早撞见这堵墙。他发现真正的敌人不是市场,也不是没有好系统,是那个无法忍受系统让自己受苦的人。 于是他把战场从电脑扳回人心。一个理性主义者,用四十年绕回了心理学,而情绪才是根本。这句话直接把我们推向他思想的地基。那句像鸡汤一样的话,无论输赢,每个人都从市场里得到了他真正想要的。 有些人似乎喜欢亏钱,所以他们通过亏钱赢了。这句话的地基是一种彻底的镜子,你的一切结果都是内心的投射, 没有运气,没有随机,只有你想要的和你不想要的。他有力量,他把交易员从怪市场逼回看自己,这是进步的起点。但作为关于世界如何运作的真理,他藏着全场最深的陷阱。这句话无法被证伪,而正是这个不可证伪性, 抽掉了他整座大厦的地基。想象一个交易员学了赛克塔的一切纪律完美,却撞上趋势失效的震荡年代,破产了。按他的框架,答案是因为他潜意识里想输。看出问题了吗?这个框架无法区分因错而亏和因运气或时代而亏。 凡赢就是你想赢,凡输就是你想输。他把所有结果吸进,抑制,这个黑洞因此永远正确,也因此什么都没说。 现在把刀转向赛克塔本人。他封神那些年,正是趋势跟踪的黄金时代,布雷顿森林体系崩溃,货币自由浮动,一九七零年代,大通胀,商品市场出现历史级大趋势,那是一个专为他这套打法量身定制的时代。 而他的地基,恰恰没有能力问出这个问题。我的二十五万倍收益里,有多少是记忆,多少是时代?因为框架里根本没有运气的位置。 这就是第一刀。一个把所有结果都归于意志的框架,天然看不见让他成立的那个时代,他让最大的赢家,恰好成了最看不清自己为何而赢的人。但上面那一刀,还停在赛克塔个人层面,往下挖,还有两铲。第一铲,它只有一把锤子, 自我归因不是地基,它只是一个更冷的东西,作用在命运这个层面上的产物。赛克塔一生只有一个算法,套了三遍。 套在市场上,是趋势跟踪。顺,有效的砍,无效的套在自己身上,是交易部落放大。赢的情绪止损,输的情绪套在命运上,就是每个人都得到了他想要的。 他不是有一套系统,外加一套人生观,他只有一把锤子,于是市场心理,命运在他的收益里,在你为什么听得到这句话里, 一九七零年代,成百上千人用着几乎一样的趋势系统,绝大多数爆仓消失了。施瓦格只采访了活下来的砍掉亏损被听见,不是因为它,真是因为它幸存 而幸存,被你误读成了真。更狠的是,这砍的不是赛克塔一个人,是整个交易圣经。这个文体 说的对,却运气差的人不写书,说的错,却运气好的人会写。你读到的每一条交易格言,都先通过了幸存者的编辑,再往下溯源到。物种砍损三连,是普世真理,还是某个物种的生存本能,是后者? 赛科塔是一个极特定的物种,多市场正偏态、低胜率、多下注的趋势跟踪者,他靠在几十个市场下小注,忍受大量小亏等极少数巨型趋势活着,他怕的不是判断错,是爆仓归零。 他优化的是长期几何复利。在这个生态位里,单笔死扛等于物种灭绝。所以砍损是绝对本能,但换个物种就是毒药 价值投资者靠的恰恰是别人砍损时死扛加仓,机械止损会让他在最该买的底部割肉。做市商靠价差周转趋势对他无意义。实业者认亏离场,会让他在每个创业低谷解散团队。 让赛科塔交所有人交易,等于让一条鱼交一只鸟呼吸第一要义是浮上水面,而这里是最后的基岩。 连稳定的物种本身都是假的。市场是反身性的,当足够多人信奉趋势跟踪并下注,趋势本身就被这些信徒创造,再被它们拥挤的交易杀死。 赛科塔那个物种,是一九七零年代货币动荡生出来的,又被后来无数模仿者的拥挤杀死的。 所以最深的那句话,把我自己的溯源到物种,也一病先发,不存在普世真理,也不存在稳定的物种本能,只存在某原则,在某段时间被市场奖励,于是长出一批信徒,信徒的拥挤,又亲手废掉这个原则。 这个自视循环,塞克塔,批判他的我,以及正在找答案的你,都在这个循环的某一环,误把此刻还没他当成了脚下是基岩到底了,不是挖穷了,是再挖一层,就是任何关于市场的确定性陈述,都会自我消解, 那不是更深的洞见,是洞的尽头。本身我甚至要老实交代,我用的草原和损势是动的尽头。本身我甚至要老实交代,我用的草原和尼想书一样,不可证伪。 进化心理学的适应故事是出了名的事后编,我批他把一切归进抑制黑洞,我自己把一切归进基因黑洞,是同一种把戏。穿了件更体面的衣服,我的刀刃和他一样钝,好说点能用的, 如果你正用着不能亏的钱,指望交易短期翻身,每天为账户失眠。以下先别执行,你现在需要的不是更好的交易工具,是先解决必须靠交易翻身的结构性压力。用认知工具对抗现金流问题,只会让你多一层自责。 先离场,稳住生活第一个补丁,先问物种,抄下任何你信奉的交易真言,查清说话人靠什么物种活着,趋势价值,做事?还是卖客? 然后问自己,我和他同物种吗?这个适合盲从大 v 的 人,不适用已有稳定体系,再质疑反而动摇执行的人。第二个补丁,记时代账 复盘你最赚的一笔,硬写两栏,第一栏我做对了什么,第二栏环境送了我什么?第二栏至少写三条。这个适合开始飘的人,不适用正处自我怀疑会被加重无力感的人。那种情况,先跳过 第三个补丁,把我想书翻译回来,每当想用我潜意识想书解释亏损时,改写成可检验的话,比如我在某条规则上没执行,或者这次是市场结构变了,与执行无关。 这个适合过度自我归罪者。不适用,习惯甩锅市场从不看自己的人。你要反过来最后说几句。 我今天带着一把演化生存加怀疑论的刀来解剖塞克塔,所以几乎必然挖出他的不可政伪和时代红利。但我心里清楚,对一个真在牌桌上的交易员,每个人都得到了他想要的这种信念,可能恰恰是他扛过回撤的心理支柱。 我拆穿了他的针,但没资格否定他的用,而且我自己那把刀也砍到了我自己。这期视频的地板同样是玻璃的, 我今天用的是演化生存视角,换成实践者或修行者视角,结论会反转。我说不可政伪是最大缺陷。在从业者眼里,恰恰是不可政伪,才让这信念有了自我实现的力量,成了穿越回撤的信仰。 同一个特征,一个是逻辑漏洞,一个是心里必须。哪个对你更真实,是你的事。留一个字,你是哪个?交易物种?趋势?价值?还是根本不知道自己是啥?如果每个人都得到了他想要的是真的,那你现在的账户余额是不是也正是你真正想要的? 还是说,这句话本身就是赢家送给输家的一份最优雅的安慰剂?最后三句话,免疫系统的工作不是让你更强,是阻止你死。他有一把锤子,于是命运在他眼里变成了钉子。你读到的每句交易格言,都先通过了幸存者的编辑。